Token Distribution Models

Kajetan Olas

15 Mar 2024
Token Distribution Models

The landscape of blockchain and cryptocurrency is continually evolving, marked by the relentless pursuit of models that not only enhance network security and decentralization but also deepen user engagement and ownership. At the heart of this evolution lies the concept of token distribution, a pivotal strategy that can transform users from passive participants into active stakeholders and owners within digital ecosystems. Token distribution is not merely about allocating digital assets; it's about creating a framework where each token serves as a beacon of ownership, rights, and incentives, aligning the interests of users with the long-term success of the platform.

As we delve into the world of token distribution, we find ourselves tracing the path of its evolution. From the foundational Proof of Work mechanisms, to the speculative fervor of ICOs, and onto the community-centric airdrops. Each era has brought with it lessons, challenges, and a deeper understanding of what it means to distribute ownership.

New trend

However, the journey has not been without its pitfalls. Many strategies, while successful in bootstrapping networks and attracting initial interest, have struggled to foster genuine user engagement or have inadvertently encouraged speculative behaviors that detract from the project's core value proposition. It's within this context that we explore the concept of "Progressive Ownership"—a model that aims to refine the token distribution process into a more nuanced, loyalty-driven approach that rewards true product-market fit and user commitment.

The Evolution of Token Distribution Models

The concept of token distribution has undergone significant transformation since the inception of blockchain technology. Each era has introduced new mechanisms for distributing tokens and lowering barriers to entry, while also revealing unique challenges. Let’s explore these pivotal stages in the evolution of token distribution models.

Proof of Work (2009–present): The Dawn of Hardware Formation

The journey began with Bitcoin, which introduced the world to the Proof of Work (PoW) model. This approach allowed anyone with computational resources to participate in network security operations, known as "mining," in exchange for tokens. This mechanism not only secured the network but also democratized access to token ownership. However, as the sector matured, mining became increasingly professionalized, requiring significant investments in specialized hardware. This shift heightened the barriers to entry, gradually sidelining the average user and emphasizing the need for substantial upfront investment. This altered the initial egalitarian vision.

ICOs (2014–2018): The Era of Capital Formation

Following the PoW era, the cryptocurrency space witnessed the rise of Initial Coin Offerings (ICOs). This period came with a new model where projects could raise capital by selling tokens directly to the public. This approach theoretically democratized investment opportunities, allowing projects to reach a broader audience beyond traditional venture capital avenues. Ethereum's ICO in 2014 stood as a landmark event, inspiring a wave of similar endeavors. However, the ICO craze also attracted numerous fraudulent schemes, leading to a regulatory crackdown and a reevaluation of this model,

Airdrops (2020–present): Bootstrapping Usage through Community Engagement

In response to the pitfalls of ICOs, the industry shifted towards a more user-centric model: airdrops. This approach involved distributing tokens freely to existing communities or users based on their engagement or historical usage. In principle this fosters a sense of ownership and participation without a direct financial investment. The era of airdrops, particularly during the "DeFi Summer" of 2020, sought to catalyze network usage and decentralization. However, the emphasis on broad, indiscriminate distribution often attracted short-term speculators rather than committed users. This complicates efforts to achieve sustained growth and genuine community development.

Reflections on the Evolution

Each era of token distribution has contributed to the blockchain landscape's growth, expanding access and participation in unique ways. From the hardware-intensive commitments of PoW, through the speculative enthusiasm of ICOs, to the community-focused aspirations of airdrops. The evolution of token distribution models reflects the cryptocurrency sector's dynamics to balance inclusivity, security, and sustainable development. Yet, as we've learned, each model comes with its set of challenges, highlighting the need for continuous innovation. New token distribution strategies come up to foster genuine user ownership and engagement in the ever-evolving digital ecosystem.

Progressive Ownership: A New Frontier

Amidst the evolution of token distribution models, with each era bringing its blend of innovation and challenge, the concept of "Progressive Ownership" emerges. This is a transformative approach aimed at realigning the incentives of blockchain applications and their users. This novel framework represents a significant pivot from previous models, focusing on nurturing genuine user engagement.

Foundation of Progressive Ownership

Progressive ownership stands on the idea that tokens should be distributed to users progressively for their contributions to the network. This model asserts that achieving product-market fit remains paramount and that token distribution should complement, not precede this fit.

In the realm of progressive ownership, tokens become a means to deepen users' commitment to an application. They transform active users into stakeholders with a vested interest in the platform's success. This approach aims to move beyond the shortcomings of indiscriminate airdrops and speculative ICOs. It proposes a more sustainable method of community building.

Key Principles and Advantages

  • Incremental Engagement: Progressive ownership advocates for rewarding users in stages, reflecting their growing engagement and value to the ecosystem. This method encourages long-term participation and deters speculative behavior by closely aligning token incentives with genuine user activity and contributions.
  • Opt-in Ownership: Central to this model is the concept of opt-in ownership, where users have the choice to convert their earned incentives or revenue shares into tokens representing a more profound stake in the project. This voluntary transition from user to owner ensures that tokens are held by those most aligned with the project's long-term vision and success.

Implementing Progressive Ownership

Successful implementation of progressive ownership requires careful planning and a deep understanding of user behavior and incentives. Projects must first establish a clear value proposition and product-market fit, creating an ecosystem where users’ contributions are quantifiable and rewardable. Following this, a transparent and accessible mechanism for transitioning users from passive beneficiaries of revenue share to active token holders must be established, ensuring clarity around the benefits and responsibilities of ownership. 

Example Implementation - Project Catalyst

Project Catalyst is a Cardano-based initiative. It’s a decentralized funding mechanism that invites community members to propose projects, which are then voted on by ADA holders. Successful proposals receive funding in ADA, with over $79 million allocated to fund more than 1600 projects by March 2024. This process not only democratizes innovation within the Cardano ecosystem but also aligns with the principles of progressive ownership by giving token holders a vested interest in the network's growth and success. Through Project Catalyst, Cardano effectively engages its community in governance and decision-making, fostering a deeper sense of ownership and participation among ADA holders.

Conclusion

By aligning token incentives with genuine user engagement projects can pave the way for more sustainable development. Such an approach not only deepens user loyalty and retention but also fosters a more vibrant, participatory community. This is the groundwork for the next generation of Champions that will spread the knowledge about your platform.

If you're looking for ways to foster the adoption of your DeFi project, please reach out to contact@nextrope.com. Our team is ready to help you create a strategy that will grow your user base and ensure long-term growth.

FAQ

How to go about designing token distribution in practice?

  • It's a good idea to take inspiration from projects similar to yours, which succeded in terms of fostering progressive ownership.

Are airdrops effective?

  • Yes. Despite all their shortcomings, if implemented correctly airdrops can do great for marketing purposes for relatively low cost.

Why is fostering an ownership-based culture important?

  • Because if your users feel like they partially own the project, then they will contribute to the development process, and share that project with all their friends.

Most viewed


Never miss a story

Stay updated about Nextrope news as it happens.

You are subscribed

Aethir Tokenomics – Case Study

Kajetan Olas

22 Nov 2024
Aethir Tokenomics – Case Study

Authors of the contents are not affiliated to the reviewed project in any way and none of the information presented should be taken as financial advice.

In this article we analyze tokenomics of Aethir - a project providing on-demand cloud compute resources for the AI, Gaming, and virtualized compute sectors.
Aethir aims to aggregate enterprise-grade GPUs from multiple providers into a DePIN (Decentralized Physical Infrastructure Network). Its competitive edge comes from utlizing the GPUs for very specific use-cases, such as low-latency rendering for online games.
Due to decentralized nature of its infrastructure Aethir can meet the demands of online-gaming in any region. This is especially important for some gamer-abundant regions in Asia with underdeveloped cloud infrastructure that causes high latency ("lags").
We will analyze Aethir's tokenomics, give our opinion on what was done well, and provide specific recommendations on how to improve it.

Evaluation Summary

Aethir Tokenomics Structure

The total supply of ATH tokens is capped at 42 billion ATH. This fixed cap provides a predictable supply environment, and the complete emissions schedule is listed here. As of November 2024 there are approximately 5.2 Billion ATH in circulation. In a year from now (November 2025), the circulating supply will almost triple, and will amount to approximately 15 Billion ATH. By November 2028, today's circulating supply will be diluted by around 86%.

From an investor standpoint the rational decision would be to stake their tokens and hope for rewards that will balance the inflation. Currently the estimated APR for 3-year staking is 195% and for 4-year staking APR is 261%. The rewards are paid out weekly. Furthermore, stakers can expect to get additional rewards from partnered AI projects.

Staking Incentives

Rewards are calculated based on the staking duration and staked amount. These factors are equally important and they linearly influence weekly rewards. This means that someone who stakes 100 ATH for 2 weeks will have the same weekly rewards as someone who stakes 200 ATH for 1 week. This mechanism greatly emphasizes long-term holding. That's because holding a token makes sense only if you go for long-term staking. E.g. a whale staking $200k with 1 week lockup. will have the same weekly rewards as person staking $1k with 4 year lockup. Furthermore the ATH staking rewards are fixed and divided among stakers. Therefore Increase of user base is likely to come with decrease in rewards.
We believe the main weak-point of Aethirs staking is the lack of equivalency between rewards paid out to the users and value generated for the protocol as a result of staking.

Token Distribution

The token distribution of $ATH is well designed and comes with long vesting time-frames. 18-month cliff and 36-moths subsequent linear vesting is applied to team's allocation. This is higher than industry standard and is a sign of long-term commitment.

  • Checkers and Compute Providers: 50%
  • Ecosystem: 15%
  • Team: 12.5%
  • Investors: 11.5%
  • Airdrop: 6%
  • Advisors: 5%

Aethir's airdrop is divided into 3 phases to ensure that only loyal users get rewarded. This mechanism is very-well thought and we rate it highly. It fosters high community engagement within the first months of the project and sets the ground for potentially giving more-control to the DAO.

Governance and Community-Led Development

Aethir’s governance model promotes community-led decision-making in a very practical way. Instead of rushing with creation of a DAO for PR and marketing purposes Aethir is trying to make it the right way. They support projects building on their infrastructure and regularly share updates with their community in the most professional manner.

We believe Aethir would benefit from implementing reputation boosted voting. An example of such system is described here. The core assumption is to abandon the simplistic: 1 token = 1 vote and go towards: Votes = tokens * reputation_based_multiplication_factor.

In the attached example, reputation_based_multiplication_factor rises exponentially with the number of standard deviations above norm, with regard to user's rating. For compute compute providers at Aethir, user's rating could be replaced by provider's uptime.

Perspectives for the future

While it's important to analyze aspects such as supply-side tokenomics, or governance, we must keep in mind that 95% of project's success depends on demand-side. In this regard the outlook for Aethir may be very bright. The project declares $36M annual reccuring revenue. Revenue like this is very rare in the web3 space. Many projects are not able to generate any revenue after succesfull ICO event, due to lack fo product-market-fit.

If you're looking to create a robust tokenomics model and go through institutional-grade testing please reach out to contact@nextrope.com. Our team is ready to help you with the token engineering process and ensure your project’s resilience in the long term.

Nextrope Partners with Hacken to Enhance Blockchain Security

Miłosz

21 Nov 2024
Nextrope Partners with Hacken to Enhance Blockchain Security

Nextrope announces a strategic partnership with Hacken, a renowned blockchain security auditor. It marks a significant step in delivering reliable decentralized solutions. After several successful collaborations resulting in flawless smart contract audits, the alliance solidifies the synergy between Nextrope's innovative blockchain development and Hacken's top-tier security auditing services. Together, we aim to set new benchmarks, ensuring that security is an integral part of blockchain technology.

Strengthening Blockchain Security

The partnership aims to fortify the security protocols within blockchain ecosystems. By integrating Hacken's comprehensive security audits with Nextrope's cutting-edge blockchain solutions, we are poised to offer unparalleled security features in our projects.

"Blockchain security should never be an afterthought"

"Our partnership with Hacken underscores our dedication to embedding security at the core of our blockchain solutions. Together, we're building a safer future for the industry."

said Mateusz Mach, CEO of Nextrope

About Nextrope

Nextrope is a forward-thinking blockchain development house specializing in creating innovative solutions for businesses worldwide. With a team of experienced developers and blockchain experts, Nextrope delivers high-quality, scalable, and secure blockchain applications tailored to meet the unique needs of each client.

About Hacken

Hacken is a leading blockchain security auditor known for its rigorous smart contract audits and security assessments. With a mission to make the industry safer, Hacken provides complex security services that help companies identify and mitigate vulnerabilities in their applications.

Looking Ahead

As a joint mission, both Nextrope and Hacken are committed to continuous innovation. We look forward to the exciting opportunities this partnership will bring and are eager to implement a more secure blockchain environment for all.

For more information, please contact:

Nextrope

Hacken

Join us on our journey to deliver top-notch blockchain tech and a safer future for the industry!